SUN TIMES
What will tomorrow bring?
August 29, 2005
BY TOM MCNAMEE Staff Reporter
How some folks dream. Then again, it's the dreamers who have made
Chicago not just big -- hey, Houston is big -- but great.
As a city, we express our dreams for the future in Millennium Park,
so perfectly realized it does not seem entirely of this time and place.
We express our dreams for the future in the grand old classics, such
as the Chicago Theatre, which we have finally -- after decades of
destruction -- learned to cherish.
And we express our dreams in that most dubious of earnest exertions
-- a plan.
Plans are boring and plans are pipe dreams, but Chicagoans know
firsthand the power of a great one -- the stunning Burnham Plan of 1909
that envisioned our breathtaking lakefront -- and so we should know to
take new plans seriously.
Specifically, this one: The Chicago Central Area Plan for 2020.
What will downtown Chicago be like in another 15 or 20 years? It's
all in the plan. It is a predictably rosy vision: the greenest, most
vibrant, most livable downtown of any big city in America.
Imagine even more parkland along the lakeshore. Imagine a Greater
Loop of office towers, parks and condos stretching to Greektown on
Halsted Street. Imagine a park on a shelf over the Kennedy Expressway
between Monroe and Madison streets. Imagine 140,000 more people living
downtown, 180,000 new jobs and 95,000 college students. Imagine riding a
bike along the river and lake, without interruption, from Chinatown to
North Avenue Beach.
IN DOWNTOWN'S FUTURE
These are some of the bigger -- or merely intriguing -- projects
being discussed that could help shape downtown for decades:
Block 37 -- Things are finally happening with this perennial site of
broken development dreams across State Street from Marshall Field. If
the CTA gets its funding for its piece of this puzzle -- providing
express-train service between here and the airports -- the combination
of transit plus shopping and nightlife could foster a Loop that never
sleeps. Outlook: Still iffy, but improved. West Loop offices -- If new
downtown office development continues, this is where many of those
offices will go because the blocks west of Union Station and the Ogilvie
Transportation Center still have plenty of surface parking lots, and the
city has zoned the land for high-rises. Outlook: Likely. McCormick Place
expansion -- The sprawling lakefront convention center is expanding to
compete with Las Vegas and Orlando for business. This is an $850 million
gamble that a new crop of business and tourism dollars can reach
downtown. Outlook: Inevitable. Lakeshore East -- This 4,900-home housing
development between Wacker Drive and Grant Park will yield a school for
condo kids. It points up a need for more convenience retailing: Hey,
it's still hard to rent a video downtown. Outlook: First stages under
construction. Trump Tower -- Ninety-two stories on the river will give
the city a riverfront promenade and a pedestrian link between Michigan
Avenue and State Street shopping. Outlook: On its way up. Fordham Spire
-- A concoction of "star-chitect" Santiago Calatrava and developer
Christopher Carley of Fordham Co., it's a proposed 110-story home on the
lakefront for multimillionaires. The twisty, drill-bit design has
supporters, but financial and zoning questions might bring it all down
to earth. Outlook: Unlikely. Central Station -- This South Loop
collection of mid- and, increasingly, high-rise condo buildings has
established a prosperous new community. A $1 billion, 1,200-unit
expansion is in the works. Outlook: Strong and steady. Union Station
addition -- The landmark transportation hub needs help. A planned
high-rise addition could provide it. One- and two-tower versions are
under consideration by Amtrak, which is deciding on a developer.
Outlook: Far, far off. Transit loop -- It could be buses, or maybe light
rail. But the potential is there for a speedy transit connection from
the new Trump Chicago tower at Wabash north of the river to the West
Loop train stations and on to McCormick Place. Outlook: Unlikely; sounds
too much like the old "circulator" trolley plan. Park on a shelf --
Chicago perfected the concept of selling air rights -- the rights to
build over something. Planners envision employing that idea to construct
a West Loop park over the Kennedy Expressway. Outlook: Needs big-name
backers to have a chance. David Roeder
Imagine 35 million conventioneers and tourists, many of them staying
in 10,000 new hotel rooms, and many doing business at a newly expanded
McCormick Place. Imagine 7 million square feet of new retail space, with
Michigan Avenue's Magnificent Mile rolling into the State Street
shopping district. Imagine a public transportation system, anchored by a
West Loop transportation complex of trains, L trains and buses, that is
so efficient it dramatically reduces environmentally noxious automobile
traffic.
Rosy visions are the stuff of uncritical boosterism, and so it would
be easy to dismiss this new official plan for Chicago's downtown. But,
after two decades of indisputable progress, as described in earlier
installments of this Sun-Times series, Chicago has every right to feel
optimistic, to believe in itself. When the Picasso statue was unveiled
in 1967, skeptics viewed it as less a harbinger of good things to come
than as an expression of wishful thinking. The Loop was on the skids.
But, when Millennium Park's "Cloud Gate" sculpture -- The Bean -- was
unveiled last summer, it rightfully was seen as a symbolic topping-off
after years of mountain climbing.
"Man is a social animal -- that's why cities developed," said
developer Buzz Ruttenberg, of the Belgravia Group. "There is a real
dynamic downtown, an interchange of people."
Enough happy talk. What could go wrong with the grand plans for
downtown?
Everything, of course. The economy could go bust. The nation could be
rattled by another Sept. 11. A meteor could pulverize Grant Park.
Taxes a threat
But there are specifics. Like the vision thing -- we had better keep
it. Will the next mayor have it?
"I would say if Rich Daley is mayor, I, too, will have a rosy view,"
said Stanley Tigerman, the well-known architect. "If he's not, I won't.
Daley has become our 21st century Daniel Burnham."
Tigerman, like many others interviewed for this series, casts Daley
as the rare political leader who has a larger vision of what a place can
be, not only in terms of jobs and garbage pickup, but also in its
ecological aesthetics -- its green spaces, river walks, boulevards and
great architecture. Beyond that, Daley's admirers say, he turns those
visions into reality.
"Others could be mayor, of course, but I doubt you'd see any
proactive input from the city," Tigerman said. "It would only come from
the developers, and we know the private sector cares only about money."
And there is the property-tax thing -- critics say it threatens to
kill downtown growth. Property taxes run about $7.18 a square foot for
downtown office space, according to the Building Owners & Managers
Association. Property taxes in the suburbs outside Cook County run about
$4 less a square foot. That being the case, a corporation looking to
rent, say, 100,000 square feet could save $400,000 a year by choosing
the suburbs over the Loop.
Improving public transit
"Unless Chicago and Cook County do something about property-tax
reform, we'll have a pretty hard time attracting new business," said Ron
Vukas, executive vice president of BOMA. "Can you think of any major
corporation that has moved to Chicago in the last 20 years other than
Boeing?"
Vacancy rates in downtown office buildings already stand at 18
percent or higher.
"My solution is to put together a dream team and identify industries
and go after them with a vengeance," said Gerald J. Roper, president of
the Chicagoland Chamber of Commerce. "How about Humana in Louisville?
Create a package to bring them here. You gotta go after things."
And then there is the transportation thing. The 2020 Plan calls for
"growth without gridlock" by making major -- and expensive --
improvements to downtown's public transportation system. The biggest
enhancement would be a West Loop Transportation Center, along Clinton
Street west of the Chicago River, where buses, trains and high-speed
rail would converge. From there, commuters would board energy-efficient
buses to travel briskly along dedicated roads to all parts of the
downtown area.
"You need strong transit systems, or you could lose some assets,"
said MarySue Barrett, president of the Metropolitan Planning Council.
"We've got great goals, but we're just not taking the steps we need to
take. Like bus rapid transit -- a tool we're just not using. It would be
a bus but feel more like rapid transit -- like the people-mover at
O'Hare. The bus pulls up, and the whole side opens for passengers, and
the light stays green, and it's great."
The Bean, as a symbol
In 1967, one Mayor Daley unveiled a statue that became an
international symbol of Chicago -- the Picasso. But many of us couldn't
make heads or tails of it. What kind of Chicago was this? In 2004, a
second Mayor Daley first unveiled a statue that also is likely to become
a symbol of Chicago -- The Bean. And this one we get.
The Bean is nothing less than a massive mirror. It reflects a Chicago
delighted to look at itself.

|